Creative Practice Review

The following essay was written by Karl Richard while studying sound art and design at UAL. It reviews the creative practice of the New Zealand born artist Sally Ann McIntyre. McIntyre’s work is highly responsive to place and includes facets of sound art, the creative repurposing of radio, as well as utilizing field recordings to investigate issues hidden within recording media histories, ecology, society and activism.

New Zealand’s Sally Ann McIntyre, a curator for the international Radia Network, utilizes experimental radio broadcasting techniques, field recording practices and pre-electrical sound technologies to re-imagine and engage in ecological discourses relating to modern-day media programming. (Ingleton, 2015; McIntyre, 2015/c) Given her original background in radiobroadcasting, it’s of little surprise that her works perceptively unravel political and philosophical frameworks about how radio/sound art and sound ecology can be viewed in today’s global society. (McIntyre, 2015/b, at 11min)

While Raymond Murray Schafer’s influence is evident, McIntyre is careful to delineate her practice from his, taking issue with Schafer’s “bucolic and nostalgic view” of nature and his problematic notion about radio transmission being “a way of listening without inhabiting”. (Novero, 2013, p. 36, McIntyre, 2015/b, at 5min) Certainly she is not being sanctimonious. As if in respect to Schafer’s notions on acoustic-ecology, her 2009 “Shouting Over the Music, a Dawn Chorus for Walter and Olivier” saw her team up with the University of Melbourne to investigate how traffic noise caused urban birds to change their song’s pitch. (McIntyre, 2010) However, McIntyre wonders (as have others) whether it is problematic to separate man from wilderness? (Thoreau, 2004, pp. 111-366; Hutchins, 2012; Wright to Carlyle, 2015) Certainly Ackerman (2012, p. 38) notes our bodies are made up of 9 times more bacterial cells than human, suggesting that each human being can be seen as a type of wilderness too.

Aside from investigating boundaries, McIntyre’s work perceptively attunes to Tetsuo Kogawa’s idea about the inherent flaw of analyzing radio via the concepts of ‘sender’ and ‘receiver’. (Kogawa, 2008, pp. 407-409; McIntyre, 2015/b, at 3min) To emphasize this, her work creates active rolls for both producer and receiver, as seen with her “Notes Towards a Library of Superlative Trees, Transmission for Eucalyptus Regnans”, where she investigates common themes running throughout her works: non-human communication, environmental displacement of species, and broadcast as an electromagnetic signaling medium (radio waves being part of the electromagnetic spectrum) to transmit sounds of trees (made-up of electromagnetic matter) in one locus back to trees in another locus. (Novero, 2013, p. 36; Butcher, 2014; McIntyre, 2015, at 1hr 11min)

Coupling interactive “media art” with Kogawa’s “Mini FM” concept, McIntyre makes clear the aspect of mobile activism within her practice. (McIntyre, 2006, p. 55; Novero, 2013, p. 34; McIntyre, 2015/b, at 6min) During her 2012 “Wild Creations” residency on the remote bird sanctuary island of Kapiti in New Zealand, McIntyre drew on Kogawa’s ideas to justify a mobile radio/sound art project (powered by solar panels and battery) that allowed her to interact directly and sensitively with the environment, creating art that better reflected its locality, challenging the anthropocentric “look-a-like” culture of established broadcast media. (Novero, 2013, p. 34; McIntyre, 2015/b, at 13min) As part of this residency she transmitted “Collected Silences for Lord Rothschild”, which used Electronic Voice Phenomenon recordings from two mounted specimens of extinct New Zealand bird, silently in to the forest without any radio receivers to ‘voice’ the audio. (Novero, 2013, p. 36; McIntyre, 2015/b, at 27min) Here McIntyre uses the silencing of these Cagean silences as a method of mourning the lost sounds of these birds that were driven to extinction by British collectors at the turn of the 20th century. (McKinnon, 2013, pp. 71-72, McIntyre, 2015/b, at 1hr 5min) She also adds that it “acknowledges our complicity in the destruction of complex ecosystems”. (McIntyre, 2015/b, at 1hr 17min) Ironically, this piece highlights an interesting paradox within the idea of ecology itself. As McKinnon (2013, pp. 71-72) writes, “acoustic ecology, while deeply concerned for the audible presence of select sounds, is predicated on the acoustic silencing of others.” While McIntyre does not specify any parallels, the practice of stoat trapping on Kapiti’s reserve poetically reflects this notion. (Novero, 2013, p. 44; Miskelly & Powlesland, 2013 pp. 1+4-5)

McIntyre’s more recent “Edison Ledges (diagram for twelve archival silences)” investigates the materiality of silence by inverting “digital archival sound preservation” methodologies to remove all the programmed sounds from several Edison wax cylinder recordings c.1890-1920, leaving only the “silences” (or “unwanted” sounds). Here she explores the history of sound via the medium it is preserved upon and the processes used to record it. (Madeleine, 2015; McIntyre, 2015/c) As if in a multifaceted manner, perhaps her work with silence (here and elsewhere) nods toward the composer John Cage, addressing similar issues about his dislike of recording performances: “Cage’s work was designed to change with each performance”, while recordings forever lock them in stasis? (McIntyre, 2015/c; Barber, 2016; Worby, 2016) Cage (in Grubbs, 2014, p. 10) also said, records “make people think that they’re engaging in a musical activity when they’re actually not”. Perhaps, here, McIntyre leaves out the recorded music in respect of Cage’s view?

Interestingly, McIntyre’s Radio d’Oiseaux projects (named in reference to Messiaen’s Catalogue d’oiseaux) have focused on sounds, particularly bird song, being broadcast from areas they were originally captured in, creating a “temporal stratification of sounds […] through […] a technologically produced mnemonic”. (Barber, 2002, p. 303; Novero, 2013, p. 34) However, as McIntyre (2015/d) lucidly notes, “Music, clearly, can not reproduce birdsong.” In lieu of this, “Collected Huia Notations (like shells on the shore when the sea of living memory has receded)” justifies itself via the Huias’ extinction, whose song can now only be known via anthropocentric perspectives. Noting that “in the absence of the source, we have the trace of a sound, in the form of imperfect, highly subjective notation”, she collated the only four known Western musical notations of Huia song into individual piano recordings. (McIntyre, 2015/d) Each of these recordings was then transferred onto the only recording medium available when the Huia were alive: phonographic wax cylinders. (McIntyre, 2015/d) Each time a cylinder is played, it is recorded, leaving a trace of how the fragile wax medium degrades. (McIntyre, 2015/d) After successive playbacks, the sound of the piano becomes obscured and begins to resemble birdsong. (McIntyre, 2015/d) Could McIntyre again be nodding to Cage?

With manmade environmental degradation on the rise and, thus, ecological conservation becoming ever more important, McIntyre’s work resonates shamanically with its mixture of pseudo-scientific practices and perceptive insights (Vaughan, 2016). Over half of the world’s wildlife population has vanished in the last 40 years alone (Knapton, 2014). Despite “narrowcasting”, her work still reaches out to listeners across the globe, countering the incessant fanfare of deeply politicized, homogenized consumer radiobroadcast programming that seems to “dumb-down” (Simpson, 2009). Ironically McIntyre’s silences are often louder, as McKinnon (2013, p. 71) fittingly notes, “(t)o experience Cagean silence […] is to give attention to what […] is most often ignored or […] overheard (as in overlooked), by attention to what is supposed to be heard (music and speech).” Her work also pertinently echoes Bathes’ notion about post-serial music, in that it “has radically altered the role of the ‘interpreter’, who is called on to be […] the co-author of the score, completing it”. (Bathes, 1977, p. 163) While McIntyre’s transmission works provide a better realization of R. Murray Schafer’s “Wilderness Radio”, his view that “the general acoustic environment of a society can be read as an indicator of social conditions which produce it and may tell us much about the trending evolution of that society” is still a powerful one. (Schafer, 1977, p. 7) As the life support system of our Planet becomes unbalanced through mankind’s inattentive actions, McIntyre’s works prophetically call for our attention in a way that only the Palan birds of Huxley’s utopian novel “Island” ever could. (Huxley, 2005, pp. 7-11; Novero, 2013, p. 34)


ACKERMAN, J. (2012) How Bacteria in Our Bodies Protect Our Health. Scientific American. vol. 306 (6). p.36-43. Available at: [Accessed: 4th May 2016]

BARBER, C. (2002) Olivier Messiaen (1908 – 1992) In: SITSKY L. ed. Music of the Twentieth-century Avant-garde: A Biocritical Sourcebook. Westport: Greenwood Press.

BARBER, J. (2015) Records Ruin the Landscape: John Cage, the Sixties, and Sound Recording (Review). Leonardo. vol. 48 (3), pp. 305-306. Available at: [Accessed: 26th April 2016]

BATHES, R. (1977) Image Music Text. London: Fontana Press. Available at: [Accessed: 26th April 2016]

BUTCHER, G. (2014) Tour of the Electromagnetic Spectrum. Nasa. [Online] Available at: [Accessed 3rd April 2016]

CARLYLE, A., WRIGHT, M. (2015) Mark Peter Wright in conversation with Angus Carlyle. [Lecture] Held on 29th October, IMT Gallery: London.

GRUBBS, D. (2014) Records Ruin the Landscape: John Cage, the Sixties, and Sound Recording. Durham, NC, USA: Duke University Press.

HUTCHINS, G. (2012) Business and humanity are not separate to nature. The Guardian, Sustainable Business Blog, 21st November. Available at: [Accessed: 30th April 2016]

HUXLEY, A. (2005) Island. Random House, London: Vintage.

INGLETON, H. (2015) E-mail to: LCC Sound Art Community, 15th October.

KNAPTON, S. (2014) Half of world’s animals have disappeared since 1970. The Telegraph, 30th September. Available at: [Accessed: 25th April 2016]

KOGAWA, T. (2008) Radio in the Chiasme. In: GRUNDMANN, H. et al. ed. Re-Inventing Radio Aspects of Radio as Art. Frankfurt/Main, Germany: Revolver.

MADELEINE, A. (2015) The sound art of Mofo 2015: making noise in the art world. The Guardian, 23rd January. Available at: [Accessed 6th May 2016]

MCINTYRE, S. (2006) From mini FM to hacktivists: Govett-Brewster Art Gallery, New Plymouth (NZ). Flash Art. vol. 39, March April, p. 55.

MCINTYRE, S. (2010) Visible City #4: Shouting Over the Music: a Dawn Chorus for Walter and Olivier. Radiocegeste.blogspot. [Online] Posted 14th October. Available at: [Accessed: 1st May 2016]

MCINTYRE, S. (2015/a) Collected Huia Notations (like shells on the shore when the sea of living memory has receded). [Internet] Available at: [Accessed: 1st January 2016]

MCINTYRE, S. (2015/b) How to Explain Radio to a Dead Huia: Doing Transmission Art in the Field. [mp3] From a Visiting Sound Practitioner Lecture Series for 2015-16, held on 15th October, LCC Campus, UAL.

MCINTYRE, S. (2015/c) “uncentred, space is also reversible… there is nothing to grasp”: Edison Ledges (diagram for twelve archival silences). Radiocegeste.blogspot. [Online] Posted 25th October. Available at: [Accessed: 25th April 2016]

MCINTYRE, S. (2015/d) Collected Huia Notations (like shells on the shore when the sea of living memory has receded). Radiocegeste.blogspot. [Online] Posted 5th February. Available at: [Accessed: 2nd May 2016]

MCKINNON, D. (2013) Dead Silence: Ecological Silencing and Environmentally Engaged Sound Art. Leonardo Music Journal. vol. 23, pp. 71-74. Available at: [Accessed: 27th April 2016]

MISKELLY, C., POWLESLAND, R. (2013) Conservation translocation of New Zealand birds, 1863-2012. Notornis. vol. 60, pp. 3-28. Available at: [Accessed: 6th May 2016]

NOVERO, C. (2013) Birds on Air: Sally Ann McIntyre’s Radio Art. Antennae: The Journal of Nature in Visual Culture. iss. 27, pp. 31-44. Available at:

SCHAFER, M. (1977) The Soundscape: Our Sonic Environment and the Tuning of the World. Rochester, Vermont: Destiny Books.

SIMPSON, P. (2009) “Falling on deaf ears”: a postphenomenology of sonorous presence. Environment and Planning. vol: 41, pp. 2,556-2,575. Available at: [Accessed: 1st April 2016]

THOREAU, H. (2004) Walden and Other Writings by Henry David Thoreau. New York, USA: Bantam Bell.

VAUGHAN, A. (2016) Human impact has pushed Earth into the Anthropocene, scientists say. The Guardian, 7th January. Available at: [Accessed: 30th April 2016]

WORBY, R. (2016) John Cage. [Lecture] From a Sound Culture – Perception & Communication 1 lecture, held on 7th March 2016, LCC Campus, UAL.